I know this is going to sound super corny and lame but we are a group of admins and we need to care about this wiki. How many times has a user just left a message on your wall saying, "______ is a sockpuppet" and "_______ spoiled me" or whatever and you just banned them without even taking a second look at it? We need to step up our game. We all make mistakes but there comes a point where too many mistakes makes the entire team look bad.
We need to read into things. If a user says, "_______ sockpuppeted" then we need to get the details. We really need evidence that they're a sockpuppet, a confession, anything. NOT a similarity in names. I mistakenly banned Fire thinking he was a sockpuppet of EternalFire and it turned out to be wrong. A user getting banned is a big thing. We don't think so because we do it every day but it really is not just something we can brush off our shoulder.
I really need you all to re-read the rules if you're unfamiliar with them. I need everyone to start caring. If you're only an admin because, hey, why not be an admin on a wiki that I love with people that I love for a show that I love? That is not a good excuse. If you're not ready to put in 110%, then really, demote yourself. Because it's not you that matters, and you need to start thinking about the team.
Have you been told more than once that you're not doing a good job? Have people complained about you? If so, start giving a shit. If you're unsure about something, ask another admin. The phrase, "it's better to try and do badly than to not try at all" doesn't apply here. If you don't know what you're doing, don't do anything, because the more you mess up, the worse you make the admins look.
Re-read the rules. This is important.